patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

'I Want to Speak to One of My Own Kind:' A Racist Act

An incident occurred at the police station on Monday.

 

The most abject racism I've witnessed since I moved to Philadelphia about two years ago happened Monday.

I was getting the police reports from the 14th Police District on Haines Street in Germantown, just as I do every other week, when a man walked in. He was white.

He walked up to an glass partition, where police officers are stationed to talk to members of the public who come by. That's pretty regular, too.

But what followed wasn't regular at all. "I want to speak to one of my own kind," he said to the black, female officer who manned the front of the station. And he pointed to the only officer on duty that was male and white.

Did he mean he wanted to talk to a man? Or was his implication more sinister? It wasn't immediately clear, although I think everyone in the station—including two other non-officers and the officer herself—assumed as much.

"Well," she said, "I can pretend to be white and a man."

The man smirked but didn't say a word. He didn't seem to be budging from his odd request as the officer, who appeared to be nonplussed, went to the back of the office to talk to her colleague.

I assumed she would fall on her sword and bring out the male officer. That probably would have defused the situation—which hadn't yet escalated at all—to some extent. But the police had their defenses up a little bit more than that.

The original officer came back out. It was clear she was in a slightly less friendly mood than before. "He wants to know why you want to speak to him," she said. "Why you want to talk to one of your own kind."

"I want to talk to one of my own kind," he said, before losing any trace of subtlety in the matter. "He's white, I'm white."

That's when things started to break down. "That's the way it should be in this city," he said. "That's the way it should be in this country,"

He was probably looking for a fight at this point, spewing hateful speech that didn't make sense and clearly wasn't socially acceptable, especially for a man who looked to be in his 50s. And if he was looking for some form of combat through speech, it worked, because his words made the police dig in that much more.

"I don't even know if he's white," the female officer said. "Hispanic, whatever," the man retorted. "I'm Hispanic too."

"Well," the female encountered, her voice rising ever so slightly. "It's not his job to talk to you. It's my job." She asked him what she wanted to bring up.

"I'd rather not say," he said angrily. "Why can't I talk to him? ... Where is the lieutenant?"

There weren't any lieutenants in sight (who, ironically, wear white shirts). The officer he wanted to talk to, however, eventually came out. "We're all the same," he said. "If you want to talk to someone, talk to one of the officers here." He gestured toward his colleagues.

"Get me the mayor," the man said. "Get me the president!"

I know it sounds like he was mentally unstable, but on the surface, he didn't exactly give off that vibe (aside from the things he was saying). He seemed, otherwise, to be moderately aware of social cues, and that added to the situation's strange nature. It felt like I was watching an PSA on racism, edited ridiculously to ensure that no one would miss that point. Racism is bad, the PSA would teach others. Don't do this.

But this was real, and incredibly bizarre.

Things devolved quickly after that. "Out," the black officer said. "Please leave."

The man continued screaming about seeing a lieutenant but in the end she walked him out and he didn't come back. She ended up walking back in, shaking her head.

"Now I've heard it all," she said.

Racism here often bubbles up below the surface, in much more subtle ways or in private conversation. It's often not as public as that—I think it's fair to say that most of us don't feel like we're living in the 1950s in Montgomery, AL. But that's what it felt like in Germantown on Monday, if even for a short moment.

It would surprise me if the incident is officially written up, and aside from chatter among police, it'll likely be forgotten in time. But it was definitely a sad reminder that feelings like this exist here and everywhere, regardless of how far we attempt to push them down into a hole.

Related Topics: 14th Police District and Racism

Bill Simon

9:22 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

That 14th Dist. Observation you made was Isolated/throwback incident...I have watched our community come thru the 1950's and 60's when Black Folks could not eat a hot dog at Woolworth's Lunch Counter at Germantown and Chelten. The real shame in our community is the escalating poverty and murders in the NW Area. Bill Simon- Human Services Consultant - PPGSG,Inc., Block Capt. Unit Block of Montana St.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Zach Subar

9:25 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

It certainly seemed to be isolated, that's for sure.

Jon

9:33 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

What makes our neighborhoods (unfortunately) unique is the willingness, even more so, the desire of the residents to live in a racially mixed area. I don't think you can read much into an anecdotal incident involving a pretty clearly disturbed individual. I am a bit surprised, though, that the police did not take him back for some, er, "discussions."

Reply

Robert McKee

11:20 am on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

I would have to say this seems like an extreme incident, but I wouldn't say isolated. As the white half of an interracial couple I see the subtleties of racism pop up often in Philadelphia and beyond. After five years in this relationship I no longer try to justify why something happened or why someone acted the way they did. We have a long way to go and many ignorant people to beware of. Thankfully we have moved forward in leaps and bounds from the past but we have not moved beyond racism. It comes in many different forms and travels in all directions. Thankfully the NW corridor is diverse. We are proud to have moved here and look forward to its future.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

4:29 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Oh, poor you. You are so strong and valiant. The wrongful treatment you receive on a daily basis must be horrifying!! LOL.. what a loser you are.

Suzanne Fluhr

12:32 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

He wanted to speak to the Mayor or the President, but only a white person? Was he going to be in for a shock!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eric Sternfels

1:01 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Thumbs up, Suzanne & thanks for a good laugh about an unfortunate incident!

Sarah

3:38 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

This is the type of person that should be taken back and questioned! With everything going on in this country with unstable people shooting up public spaces, someone so blatantly disturbed who walks into a police station trying to cause a problem shouldn't have been just ignored.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

4:35 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Yes.. I agree.. Better yet, we should torture this uppity cracker for opening his fat mouth, right? In fact, why not start executing all racists on the spot! Surely, they should have conformed by now. Anyone who hasn't is danger to society and a threat to The Soviet...oops.. i mean..uhhh.. The United States of America! Yea!

Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

4:36 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Yea! Screw Habeas Corpus and the Constitution! Take him into questioning. The multicultural melting pot is wayyyy more important than that stupid piece of paper called "The Constitution" or whatever. Right?

Peter Johnson

4:11 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

LOL.. Who gives a crap about this? How do you even take the time to sit down and write about this? I'm sure you were shaking in your boots as the "Big Bad White Racist" went off on the poor innocent black lady. Right then and there you knew that you were a nice, upstanding, little liberal do-gooder. Zach.. hahaha Christ..

Reply

Peter Johnson

4:18 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

I know! I have an idea! Why don't you turn this into an epic novel or movie? You can go into the backgrounds of all the poeple involved. You can talk about their upbringings. Paint the man as a sadistic pedophile who hunts children down because of his own past history, during his childhood, as a rape victim. Better yet, make it his own father who raped him. A slightly overweight, beer-bellied, stubble-faced white man will do. Make sure you get a lot of shots with him in a lazy-boy couch, holding a can of Budweiser. Then, make sure you pepper the story with nice brown people who are constantly spewing "wisdom". At the very end, make sure that this racist man encounters some sort of tragedy of his own, that makes him realize that he was wrong all along, and that we are all the same. What do you think? Are you going to do it? If you do, you'll definitely get praise from every other jackass in Hollywood who has thought up the same script. LOL God i hate what this country has become because of people like you. Why don't you liberal hippies all move to Cuba with Rachel Maddow, Chris Matthews, and every professor that works at a public University.

Reply

Frank Holmes

4:58 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

"Get me the mayor. Get me the president!"

That's rich. Shoulda rounded up a stray dog for "his own kind."

And "Peter Johnson." That's rich, too. And you can call me "Dick Pole."

Reply

Peter Johnson

5:28 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Okay, "Dick Pole". Thanks for the reply.

Reply

Jim Harris

8:28 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Kudos 2 kops 4 keepin kool! This country is definitely full of hateful, unstable individuals. (LOL)

Reply

EAHAHR

9:55 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

What would have happened had the individual been Black and the Officer white? Hmmmmm?

Reply

G Allen

10:31 pm on Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Add together all the “isolated incidents” overheard in private conversations in public places, encountered in restaurants or shops and in the news, and they create a chain of experiences that not only insults one’s sensibilities, but affects one’s very sense of safety and self worth. Because these incidents are so random and unexpected, they hit the heart hard and chip away at one’s peace. For those toward whom they are directed, and for citizens like the author of this article, they at first seem absurd but later settle into the soul. Like a sight once seen cannot be unseen, they are words that cannot be unheard and a particular pain that cannot be unfelt. While it is not 1950’s Alabama, it can more often than it should, feel reminiscent, despite our country’s advancements.

I thank the author for sharing this. My heart goes out to him, the officer whose life was interrupted by this isolated incident, her coworkers, and to the offending individual whom if ill, I hope receives the treatment he requires. Unfortunately, nothing will stop such incidents until they are seen for the hateful acts that they are. They cannot be passed off as incidental or swept under a rug; we’ve learned that the rug gets so bumpy that it trips us all. The stories must be told and heard. We must collectively be offended and outraged when we hear them and collectively sympathetic and kind to those involved. Maybe caring will ease the pain and help restore a sense of safety, for us all.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

3:50 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Shut your pie-hole, you arrogant child! You are nothing more than a pathetic loser with nothing better to do than cry about all of the "injustices" you have encountered. The most pathetic part of it all is that you are probably a middle-aged white person. You disgust me and should be ashamed of yourself for being so self-hating.

Peter Johnson

3:38 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Zach Subar... Don't you have a Trayvon Martin rally to go to or something? Quit bitching and moaning online about some terrifying moment you had at the police station while you pocket-dialed your Mommy out of fear of the Big Bad Racist Latin man. You are the one that sounds racist against latinos. Do us all a favor and stop writing articles. First of all, your grammar is awful. Secondly, after reading this article, the majority of readers are more than confident that you are a pathetic virgin.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Zach Subar

10:00 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Hi Peter,

Can you point out a few instances where my grammar was awful? That would be great. I'm always up for hearing feedback, so I'd appreciate if you could let me know of a few places where I could improve for next time. Either here or at zach@patch.com.

Thanks.

Peter Johnson

3:41 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

"AngryBlackMan", you are either my absolute hero, or are living proof of every point i've ever made.

Reply

Peter Johnson

4:00 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Zubar? Can you please boot "AngryBlackMan" from the commentary section for posting hateful material?

Reply

Randolph Finkelstein

4:07 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I would like to see this conversation stay at an intellectual level. The point that Mr. Zulbar makes is a very real and valid one in 2012. Sadly there are hundreds of examples of this quiet racism going on everyday, and people that we brought over in shackles and kept in the bowels of ships for days are still being degraded. The thing is that in today's day and age this should no longer be acceptable. These acts like asking for a cop of ones own color are no different whether it is a person of color or not. All men were created equal, and therefore should be treated equally with dignity. This is a dispicable act. Let us not forget the past lest we be less of men.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

4:09 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Hey Randolph. If we want your opinion, we'll ask for it. Although, i wouldn't hold your breath.

Zach Subar

9:56 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Profanity in comments violates our terms of use, as do comments that promote racism or bigotry. So I've removed any comments that violate those terms. Please, please, please keep it civil down here.

Reply

Kaitlyn Foti

10:48 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Peter Johnson-
While we appreciate you using Patch to share your opinion, please refrain from insulting others who comment here, or the author of this article.
If you had the pleasure of meeting Zach, you would feel differently, I promise you.
Either way, we try to maintain civility in these forums. Please refrain from insults and name-calling.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Peter Johnson

1:23 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

I have no interest in meeting Zach Subar. The reason for this is because he sounds like every other Uber-Politically-Correct and Liberal journalist in America. However, if i did have the chance to meet him, i'd probably recommend that he try to be different, or think outside of the box. That's the problem with American journalism today. Everybody is so busy trying to prove that they aren't racist, that they simply ignore other problems that we have in our communities. I mean, give me a break. I've lived in the inner-city. The amount of times that I've heard insulting comments hurled at whites, or even new Asian inhabitants, is mind-boggling. I've seen them practically removed from neighborhoods all-together, due to their fear of their neighbor and fellow-man. Yet, no one reports on these stories. Google: Channon Christian & Christopher Newsom. Google:Journalists Forster and Rostami. Google: Boby and Nacy Strait. i can literally list 500 cases that the public has never heard about. It's always "drag up the old senile white racist". It get's tiring.

Peter Johnson

1:23 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

Frankly, that's probably why people are so disillusioned with the left. The Democratic Party is always scratching it's head wondering why middle class white Americans flock to the republican party in hordes, each and every election cycle, despite the fact that Republicans policies often cater to the rich. The reason is simple. People like Zach make it so that they would rather vote against their own interests, then with any party that even remotely resembles a liberal or progressive agenda.

Reply

Leave a comment